21 January 2017

Referee Analysis : Real Madrid 2-1 Malaga

21 January 2017
Santiago Bernabeu

Referee
Gil Manzano

Goals
34:52 Sergio Ramos 1-0
42:06 Sergio Ramos 2-0
62:42 Juanpi 2-1

Yellow cards [2-3]
36:27 Casemiro (Real Madrid) for foul on Fornals (Malaga)
38:12 Juankar (Malaga) for foul on Lucas Vazquez (Real Madrid)
76:56 Camacho (Malaga) for foul on Casemiro (Real Madrid)
84:02 Lucas Vazquez (Real Madrid) for foul on Recio (Malaga)
84:10 Michael Santos (Malaga) for foul on Nacho (Real Madrid)

Wrong decisions in favour: Real Madrid 7-1 Malaga
Unclear decisions in favour: Real Madrid 6-4 Malaga
________________________________________________________________________

05:07 No free-kick for possible foul Recio (Malaga) on Modric (Real Madrid)
Unclear action














05:38 No free-kick for foul Benzema (Real Madrid) on Juanpi (Malaga)
Unclear action














08:32 No free-kick for possible dangerous play Modric (Real Madrid)
Wrong decision














[31:29] No free-kick for foul Sergio Ramos (Real Madrid) on Recio (Malaga), no yellow card
Wrong decision [should have been free-kick, Sergio Ramos should have been booked]















31:51 Free-kick for possible foul Penaranda (Malaga) on Nacho (Real Madrid)
Unclear action















32:20 Free-kick for possible foul Recio (Malaga) on Ronaldo (Real Madrid)
Wrong decision














34:52 Goal Sergio Ramos (Real Madrid) 1-0

36:27 Yellow card Casemiro (Real Madrid)

38:12 Yellow card Juancar (Malaga)

38:12 Free-kick for foul Juankar (Malaga) on Lucas Vazquez (Real Madrid), yellow card
Unclear action [free-kick correct, yellow card Juankar unclear]














42:04 No free-kick for offside Sergio Ramos (Real Madrid)
Wrong decision
















42:06 Goal Sergio Ramos (Real Madrid) 2-0

44:31 No free-kick for possible foul Sergio Ramos (Real Madrid) on Juanpi (Malaga)
Unclear action














46:01 End of first half [added time was 01:00]
_____

52:32 No free-kick for possible foul Varane (Real Madrid) on Penaranda (Malaga)
Unclear action














57:27 No free-kick for possible foul Rosales (Malaga) on Ronaldo (Real Madrid)
Unclear action














62:42 Goal Juanpi (Malaga) 2-1

66:58 No free-kick for foul Luis Munoz (Malaga) on Ronaldo (Real Madrid), advantage
Wrong decision [advantage correct, should then have been free-kick]















69:06 No free-kick for possible foul Villanueva (Malaga) on Ronaldo
Unclear action














70:36 Throw-in Malaga after ball possible not crossed the touch-line after duel between Lucas Vazquez (Real Madrid) and Jony (Malaga) / after Jony (Malaga) possibly last touched the ball in duel with Lucas Vazquez (Real Madrid)
Unclear action














76:57 Yellow card Camacho (Malaga)

76:57 Free-kick for possible foul Camacho (Malaga) on Casemiro (Real Madrid), yellow card
Wrong decision [free-kick correct, Camacho should not have been booked]















84:02 Yellow card Lucas Vazquez (Real Madrid)

84:10 Yellow card Michael Santos (Malaga)

90:00+00:25 Free-kick for possible foul Rosales (Malaga) on Morata (Real Madrid)
Wrong decision














90:00+01:02 Corner Real Madrid after Demichelis (Malaga) possibly last touched the ball in duel with Morata (Real Madrid)
Unclear action















90:00+02:01 Free-kick for foul Casemiro (Real Madrid) on Juanpi (Malaga)
Wrong decision [Casemiro should have been booked and sent off for two yellow cards]















90:00+04:05 End of the game [added time was 04:00]

6 comments:

  1. Wasnt the 2-0 Ramos offside?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You might want to check the analysis at 42:04... :)

      Delete
  2. 42:04 No free-kick for offside Sergio Ramos (Real Madrid)
    Wrong decision

    Barcelona 1-1 R.Madrid. Same offside of Suarez:

    No free-kick Real Madrid for possible offside Suarez (Barcelona)
    Unclear action [correct to give advantage to attacking team]

    What is the explanation?? Barça supporters? Congratulations! A barcelona media took your work

    ReplyDelete
  3. Advantage is of course only justifiable when situation isn't clear, not if a player is clearly offside, which is here the case.

    We used that concept several times already (first time when Madrid scored 1-0 against Osasuna), check the blog :)

    ReplyDelete
  4. Realy good job. Keep it !!!

    ReplyDelete